Forget Everything You Know About Line

5 Apr 2011

Tonal drawing is all about unifying a composition
with gradation--not line. All works by Ira Korman.
There’s one thing and one thing alone that makes for a successful tonal drawing: seeing masses rather than outlines. Lines are for flow charts, architectural blueprints, and driving on the right side of the road. To a certain extent I am kidding—there are some incredible draftsmen who work solely or predominately with line. But when it comes to tonal drawings, I’m not joking—it is an emotive, immediate way to create inspiring art. It is the painter’s way of drawing because it is all about the illusion of mass by putting contrasting values side by side.

With a tonal drawing, objects jump off the page with much more life than with a line drawing because there is the suggestion of volume. That aspect of tonality—as opposed to line and contour—more closely reflects the way the human eye sees.

In practical terms, tonal drawing also enables an artist to capture an array of interesting lighting conditions: night scenes lit by fire, moonlight, or candles. By their very nature of not having lines to demarcate forms, they allow everything within a composition to unify and become part of a whole, which is a lot more difficult to do in line drawings.

But you have to choose the right materials for the job if you want a successful tonal drawing. Put down the pencil and pick up the powdered graphite, and apply it with a stump or chamois. Graphite is slightly oily and will stay where it is put, so you can work with more precision and detail. Charcoal is an obvious choice too, though it tends to swirl around more. You can also take a piece of Bristol or hot-pressed watercolor paper and cover it with a medium tone of graphite powder, then start working into it with a kneaded eraser, removing areas of light. The harder you push, the lighter the tone will get.

Night Shift, 1999, charcoal, 17 x 24.
Overpass, 1999, charcoal, 13 x 21.
Has this sent you spiraling with new ideas of how to work? I know it has for me. I’m thinking of creating moody drawings of figures coming out of darkness into the light, or atmospheric landscape drawings that create a distinctive mood or feeling that trees, hills, and sky alone can’t do.

And whether you are a dedicated painter, a draftsman, or if you dabble across media, this is the kind of artistic pursuit that rewards on all fronts, and is really an essential for any artist's evolution. It is also the kind of content you’ll find with your subscription to Drawing magazine: insights on artistic practice mixed with instruction on how to make the most of those practices in your own work. Could anything be better for the artist who never wants to stop learning? Enjoy your subscription today!


Filed under: , ,
Related Posts
+ Add a comment

Comments

Kisu wrote
on 6 Apr 2011 7:44 AM

As always, an interesting blog, Courtney!  There were some artists who were able to combine very obvious line and moody tone in the same compositions, bringing together the best of both worlds without sacrificing a sense of volume.  Degas was one of those artists, for instance.    

on 6 Apr 2011 11:23 AM

I'm one of your fans, Courtney. You've made an passionate statement for the power of tone in drawing. However, in making your case, it is not necessary to devalue line as a method of drawing.

Line can be powerful. Line can be simplicity at its best.  Line can be sensitive to the point of intimacy. Line can speak of volume and mass. Line can be a method of building tonal areas in drawing. Be slow to assign a second tier to such a mysterious, magnificent and natural way of drawing.

Paul Sullivan

on 6 Apr 2011 12:19 PM

This matches my ideas about line --- I avoid them.  My theory of painting is that you can't paint a tree, an animal, a face, a landscape, only God can do that.  As an artist, all you can do is paint the colors of the shapes of the values...only 3 things:  Color, shape and value.  Line doesn't enter in.  There are times when line is a very necessary decorative element.  Used judiciously and carefully, line can make all the difference in lifting something up off the page, but I rarely need this.  

I do line drawings when I work in watercolor, but they are hardly more than outlines and often not quite that much.  WC painters are often accused of working like a colorbook, drawing lines and filling them in.  Over time, I have drawn less and less and I never outline areas of value.  I'd like to think this makes my work a little more spontaneous and my values a little more exciting.